Deciding when to sell your home—especially in the Maine luxury and waterfront market—is a major decision. Timing can affect your sale price, competition, and how quickly your home sells.
At Balsam Realty, we closely track market conditions, buyer demand, and economic trends to help sellers make strategic, data-driven decisions. So, is now the right time to sell? Let’s take a closer look at the market.
Casco Bay Market Snapshot (January 2025)
The Casco Bay region, which includes waterfront homes from Cape Elizabeth and Falmouth Foreside to Freeport, Yarmouth, Harpswell, and the islands, remains one of Maine’s most sought-after markets.
- Median Home Price – Casco Bay Region: $825,000 (+5.8% YoY), higher than the national average increase of 4.8%.
- Average Days on Market (DOM): 45 days (luxury homes slightly longer)
- Inventory Levels: +12% YoY (more homes available, but demand remains strong)
- Buyer Activity: 40% of luxury purchases are all-cash
What Does This Mean for Maine Sellers?
✅ Home prices remain strong—buyers are still paying premium prices for well-positioned homes.
✅ Inventory is rising, but not enough to create a buyer’s market—sellers still hold leverage.
✅ Cash buyers are active, reducing concerns about financing delays.
However, with inventory increasing and mortgage rates expected to decline, competition may pick up later in 2025.
3 Reasons Why NOW is a Great Time to Sell in Maine
1. Strong Buyer Demand for Coastal & Luxury Homes
Luxury and waterfront homes in Brunswick, Freeport, South Freeport, Yarmouth, Cumberland Foreside, and Falmouth Foreside continue to attract out-of-state buyers and investors.
✔ Buyers from Boston, New York, and beyond are looking for Maine retreats with privacy and space.
✔ Move-in-ready, modern homes are selling quickly, while homes needing updates are sitting longer.
✔ Waterfront & lifestyle amenities remain top priorities—deep-water docks, private beach access, and energy-efficient upgrades all command higher sale prices.
📌 If your home is turnkey and well-prepared, now is an optimal time to list before more inventory comes on the market.
2. Prices Are at Historic Highs—But for How Long?
The Casco Bay region’s median price has increased by 5.8% YoY, keeping sellers in a strong position.
However, as more homes hit the market, buyers will have more options—potentially leading to slower sales and softer pricing later in 2025.
📌 If you're considering selling in the next 12 months, listing sooner could mean securing top dollar before the market shifts.
3. Interest Rates Are Stabilizing—Bringing More Buyers Back
- Current 30-year fixed mortgage rate: 6.5%
- Current 15-year fixed mortgage rate: 5.75%
- The Fed has signaled potential rate cuts in 2025, which could increase demand but also lead to more sellers listing their homes, increasing competition.
📌 If you want to sell in a less crowded market, listing now may be your best move.
Should You Sell or Keep Your Maine Home?
Many Maine homeowners—especially those with second homes or waterfront properties—are deciding whether to sell now at peak pricing or hold onto their home for future value appreciation or rental income.
If you're unsure, consider:
❓ Short-Term Rental Potential vs. Selling Now
- Would your home generate strong rental income as a seasonal Airbnb or luxury vacation home?
- Are you comfortable managing renters, or do you prefer a straightforward sale at a high price?
❓ Lifestyle Considerations
- Would selling now allow you to relocate, downsize, or invest in another property?
- Would keeping the home allow for future family use or generational wealth building?
📌 Balsam Realty can provide a market analysis comparing potential rental income vs. selling now for full market value.
The Best Way to Sell in 2025: Maximize Exposure & Buyer Competition
Unlike some agencies that market 40% of their listings in-house, claiming they have "ready buyers," we ensure your home reaches the full market to create maximum competition.
🚫 In-house listings limit buyer exposure, reducing your leverage.
🚫 Dual agency can create conflicts of interest—some agents work for the buyer and seller at the same time.
🚫 All Buyers will find your home when listed publicly through the MLS, Zillow, and luxury real estate platforms.
At Balsam Realty, we never limit exposure. We ensure your property reaches:
✔ Affluent buyers relocating from major metro areas
✔ Luxury investors looking for Maine waterfront & coastal properties
✔ Buyers seeking move-in-ready homes in Freeport, Yarmouth, Falmouth & beyond
More visibility = more competition = a better sale price for you.
Should You List Now or Wait? Let’s Talk.
We help sellers evaluate timing, strategy, and pricing to maximize their sale.
📩 Contact Balsam Realty today for a personalized market analysis.
📞 207-865-0123 | 🌎 BalsamRealty.com | homework@balsamrealty.com
Connect